Domitian was a Roman emperor who succeeded his brother Titus in 81AD. There is some debate over what sort of emperor he was – good or bad.
For much of
the time since his death in 96AD, the Roman emperor Domitian has had a very bad
press. His name is on many lists of “bad emperors” who behaved with cruelty and
tyranny, and under whose rule everyone went in fear of their lives. However,
his reputation has had something of an upwards revision in recent years, and it
may well be that he deserves to move across the line that divides bad emperors
from good ones.
His early
life
His full name
was Titus Flavius Domitianus and he was born at Rome in 51AD, the younger son
of Vespasian, who was a successful Roman general destined to become one of the
Empire’s better emperors. His elder brother was Titus, who also became emperor.
The year 69AD
was the “year of the four emperors”, during which Rome went through a period of chaos following
the overthrow of Nero the previous year. Vespasian was declared emperor by the
eastern legions on 1st July, while he was on campaign in Palestine accompanied by
Titus. Domitian, as the son of a rival claimant, was therefore in grave danger
from the incumbent, Vitellius, and he only narrowly escaped with his life by
staying in hiding until Vitellius was overthrown and murdered in December.
Domitian, aged only 18, then emerged from hiding and took control of the city
until his father arrived to accede to the imperial throne.
Under
Vespasian, Domitian took very little part in government, not having been
entrusted with any official role by his father, and he spent most of his time
living on a country estate and devoting himself to artistic pursuits such as
poetry. There does seem to be some evidence that Domitian gave way to
temptation in some respects, which is hardly surprising seeing that he was a
young man with plenty of money and time on his hands and with nothing to do but
enjoy himself. The fact that he had no official role would have led to behaviour
that would ensure that no such role would ever come his way. History is full of
“playboy princes” of whom the same story could be told.
When
Vespasian died in 79AD the imperial power passed effortlessly to his elder son,
Titus, who also had no role to offer Domitian. One thing to remember is that
the brothers were hardly close. Titus was eleven years older than Domitian, and
had been fighting alongside his father for much of Domitian’s childhood. They
therefore hardly knew each other.
However, it
seems highly unlikely that Domitian had anything to do with Titus’s early death
in 81AD at the age of 40. This was almost certainly due to natural causes, and
not poison as alleged by some historians based on comments by contemporaries.
It is apparently true that Domitian did not show a lot of grief at his
brother’s death but instead made every effort to secure the imperial crown for
himself, but he would have remembered the chaos caused by the uncertainty that
preceded his father’s accession and would therefore have been keen to ensure
that no rival claimants could gather support in opposition to him.
Domitian as
emperor
It is worthy
of note that one of Domitian’s first acts as emperor was to commission a
magnificent triumphal arch in Rome to honour his late brother. The Arch of
Titus survives (somewhat restored) to this day, and has been the model for many
later monuments, such as the Arc de Triomphe in Paris
and Marble Arch in London .
Domitian also
continued the work begun by Titus to rebuild much of the city that had been
destroyed by the fire of 80AD. However, large parts of the city had been
neglected for a number of years, right through the reigns of his father and
brother. Domitian was therefore making good the oversights of his predecessors
as well as constructing many new public buildings. This largesse made him very
popular with the common people of Rome ,
especially as he was able to introduce economic reforms that meant that all
this work did not bankrupt the city or the empire.
However, in
order to do all this, Domitian worked largely without consulting the Senate, which
was therefore sidelined. Vespasian and Titus had favoured a system that was
almost republican, with the institutions of government being given proper roles
to play. Domitian brought all those institutions into his own hands, making the
important decisions himself. He therefore ruled as a despot, doubtless seeing
himself as an enlightened one, although this was an excellent way to make
enemies of those who thereby lost power and influence.
In military
matters, despite having no military experience prior to becoming emperor,
Domitian enjoyed some success. His aims were mainly defensive, particularly at
the difficult frontier in Germany
along the River Rhine, where a system of defensive walls, forts and roads known
as the “Limes Germanicus” was built (“limes” is a two-syllable word, the plural
of which is “limites” hence the English “limit”).
However, it
is probably true that Domitian made more of his limited military victories than
was warranted. For example, he claimed a triumph in his campaign against the
Chatti tribe of central Germany
in 83AD. From 86 to 90AD he was involved in wars against the Dacians (in modern-day
Hungary and Romania), where the opposing King Decebalus proved to be a difficult
opponent who was not to be defeated until 104AD, by Trajan. Domitian was forced
to make peace on terms that involved the payment of tributes to Dacia, and this
was a considerable humiliation to Rome that some senators were not prepared to
forgive.
The brightest
spot in the expanding empire was Britain ,
where General Agricola was able to push the border into present-day Scotland , there being evidence of Roman activity
as far north as Inverness . However, he was
recalled to Rome
in 85AD, possibly because Domitian was jealous of his successes; at least this
was the view of the historian Tacitus. On the other hand, Agricola had been
governor for seven years, on top of several previous years as a legionary
commander, so perhaps it was high time for him to return to Rome , although he was not appointed to any
fresh command.
The pattern
of Domitian being popular with the people but less so with the patrician class
repeated itself in the Army. He was well liked by the common soldiers, among
whom he spent a lot of time in the field, and he raised their pay. However, his
personal lack of military competence gave rise to opposition and conspiracies.
Domitian
tried to reform Roman morals among the upper classes and to restore the cult of
emperor worship, although directed towards his deified father and brother
rather than himself. He imposed strict discipline in religious matters, with
vestal virgins who fell from grace being condemned to death.
It is also
true that a number of senators were executed on Domitian’s orders. However,
whether this constituted the “reign of terror” of which historians were later
to accuse him is another matter.
There were
therefore many reasons for some people in high places to want Domitian out of
the way, and this led eventually to his assassination on 18th
September 96AD. A plot was hatched that involved a number of palace officials,
chief among them being a steward named Stephanus who had feigned an injury some
days before so that he could hide a dagger under his bandages. When the attack
came, several conspirators struck the blows.
His
reputation
Domitian is
one of those emperors on whom the “the jury is out”. When history is written by
people in the pay of others who have suffered at the hands of the person in
question, it is unlikely to be fair or balanced. At this distance of time it is
impossible to know the ultimate truth of what may or may not have happened, and
so there is much reading between the lines to be done.
It seems
fairly certain that Domitian, as well as being a sound administrator, was a
strong ruler who abandoned some of the more conciliatory policies of his two
predecessors, so it is hardly surprising that he made enemies. That he was a
despot is quite evident. Whether or not he was a benevolent one is the point at
issue.
© John
Welford
No comments:
Post a Comment